INDEX INVESTING, PART II - ADVANTAGES OF INDEX INVESTING


By Matt McCracken - Posted on 15 April 2007

There are a large number of American financial advisors who are deeply committed to the idea that MPT is one of the greatest financial innovations in investing since the creation of the equity markets themselves. I refer to these Index fund advisors as MPTer’s. I will argue that while there are better solutions than indexing, it does provide a sound means of allocating capital. Unfortunately, too many American financial advisors charge their clients far too much for this solution.
  1. You’ll never do much worst than average (in spite of countless assertions to the contrary by your high school English professor)
  2. Since the market has historically gone up 2/3 of the time, you’ll make money more often then you’ll lose it (Odds better than Vegas, baby!)
  3. Index investing is completely rational and therefore eliminates emotional errors in investing (I actually would disagree with this on certain levels. Over short periods of time, it eliminates emotional errors but many index fund advisors make large, macro errors which I’ll cover later.)
  4. Keeps investing costs to a minimum (Bankrupting those good-for-nothing bums on Wall St)
  5. It is a tax-friendly strategy because it defers realized gains (Bankrupting those good-for-nothing bums in Washington)
While I’ll agree that you could do a lot worse than using an index investing approach, I personally believe that it has numerous disadvantages which is why I am not a proponent of index investing. In the next post in this series, I’ll cover the many disadvantages of index investing.

Contact

To discuss your portfolio, please fill out the form below.

WEBSITE DISCLAIMER and COPYRIGHT STATEMENT

McCracken & Company (MAC) is a registered as an Investment Adviser with the State of Texas Securities Board. Our firm's registration with the State of Texas Securities Board is not an endorsement for the firm. The information on this world wide website is for general information purposes only. The MAC is not liable for any decision based on the information of this website. All content expressed herein constitute the judgment of the staff of the MAC. The information contained on this website is from sources that we believe to be reliable however we do not guarantee its accuracy or completeness.

The works of authorship contained in this website in the domain www.investorsadv.com, including but not limited to all design, text, images, charts or other data are owned by McCracken & Company and may not be copied, reproduced, transmitted, displayed, distributed, altered, stored or sublicensed for subsequent use in whole or in part in any manner without written permission from McCracken & Company.